Sydney Lyric, Pyrmont · Thursday 19 November 2026
Photos by Jeff Busby
Review by: Alan Connor
Sweet Caroline, Sweeter Sequins

I walked into the Sydney Lyric in Pyrmont on a wave of sequined jackets, diehards and downright enthusiasm for a man whose songs have soundtracked every karaoke bar and 50th birthday I’ve ever been to. I took my seat in the dress circle, in a packed house, ready to meet the man behind them. I’d always pictured him as a Midwestern troubadour. He’s a Flatbush, Brooklyn kid, which I should have clocked after a decade in New York.
The show starts at the end. An old Neil Diamond (Terence Crawford) sits with his therapist (Monica Sayers), talking about the “clouds” that follow him around and how his 3rd wife finds him difficult to be around. Anthony McCarten’s book starts there, and we work our way back from it. It’s a jarring way in, warts and all, but it pays off. We meet a shy kid who spent his childhood in his bedroom with imaginary friends, until a guitar showed him the one place he felt sure of himself.

The early years are the usual grind: songs written for other people, a wife and kid at home, not much money. Ellie Greenwich, the Brill Building songwriter-producer who gave him his big break, gets him thinking more positively. Then comes my favourite scene of the night, set in The Bitter End, the Greenwich Village coffeehouse where he cut his teeth. A tiny stage, a crowd of maybe twenty close enough to count the sweat on his brow, and Diamond walking out in front of them. Beforehand he’s a bag of nerves. Afterwards he’s transformed. The high doesn’t last. It fades, as they do, and I’m not convinced he ever worked out what to do about that.
The young Diamond is Will Swenson, and he is the show. He’s on stage for the best part of the night, and he has the nerves of the coffee-house kid and the swagger of the showman, and moves between the two without a seam. Swenson’s voice sounds like it gargles with rocks and whisky before it’s properly awake, and it never tires. He carries the songs tremendously, the scenes in between and the weight of a man who spends most of his life wondering whether he’s good enough. By the time Neil Diamond’s Bang Records deal arrives, with the pressure for the next hit and the slow collapse of his first marriage, you’re fully on his side.

The story gets you through the door, but the hits are why you stay, and the show knows it. The programme lists 29 numbers, filleted down from a career of thirty-odd albums, and they arrive thick and fast: Cherry, Cherry, Cracklin’ Rosie, Forever in Blue Jeans, Hello Again, Song Sung Blue. Then there’s I’m a Believer, which I’d always filed under the Monkees. They had the hit, but Diamond wrote it. And Solitary Man, which I’d happily have told you was my favourite Johnny Cash song, right up until I learned Cash was the one covering Diamond. For a man I’d mostly met at karaoke, it was a reminder of how much of my life he’d quietly written the songs for.
And then, Sweet Caroline. We find him in a cheap Memphis hotel room, rolling the dice, with everything on the line. In thirty minutes he comes up with the song that will define him. You know the opening riff. You know the “womp, womp, womp” of the chorus. And you will clap your hands, I promise. Everyone in the theatre was moving.
The crowd’s devotion makes sense once you know the history. Diamond toured Australia seven times between 1976 and 2015, and Hot August Night spent 29 weeks at number one here. For a lot of the people around me, this felt less like a night at the theatre than a reunion. It was a diehard crowd, here to sing along, and sing they did. The house had a few more years on the clock than your average theatre crowd, but my plus-one, who’d come in knowing only Sweet Caroline, loved it too.

It isn’t all sunshine for Neil. The relentless touring, the movie roles, the entourage on the payroll and a home life fraying at the edges all take their toll. The scene that stayed with me comes at the end of a gruelling tour. Diamond gets home to LA a day early, to find his second wife heading out to dinner with Barbra Streisand. To most of us that’s the invitation of a lifetime. To him it’s the last thing on earth he wants. Maybe the lonely Flatbush kid just wanted a bit of peace, a guitar, his imaginary friend, and the clouds that hover whenever he’s not on stage. By the time wife number three arrives, the show lets him seem a lot happier.
Through all of it, the older Diamond watches from his chair, and Terence Crawford plays him with a stillness that makes you lean in. He doesn’t come alive until halfway through. When he does, he opens up a voice with real weight and gravel behind it, and the whole theatre sits up. It’s rousing, and it reminds you that you don’t need much to feel alive: a purpose, a guitar and a few terrific songs.

My one minor quibble is that the therapist and old Neil sit at the edge of the stage all night. It’s a handsome idea, but by the end I wanted them to leave so the party could get on without them.
Emilio Sosa’s costumes take us from 60s casual to peak-Diamond, sequins so dazzling I should have brought my sunglasses. They command the stage as much as the cast does. And a word for the nine-piece band under music director Nigel Ubrihien, who were awesome and gave every one of those songs its muscle.
It runs just over two hours, including a twenty-minute interval that, judging by a bar queue thirty deep when the bell rang, is more of a suggestion.
A rollicking good night, and a deep dive into the mind of the songwriter. The show’s Diamond never finds a lasting cure for the clouds. For a couple of hours in Pyrmont, the rest of us did.
Four stars out of five. Five if you love Neil Diamond, and the house was full of them. I’m not quite a diehard, but I’m closer than when I walked in.
The Australian premiere of A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical is playing at Sydney Lyric from 14 November and continuing to QPAC’s Lyric Theatre from 20 March 2027 followed by Her Majesty’s in Adelaide from 23 May. Tickets are on sale from https://theneildiamondmusical.com.au/.
Share "Review: A Beautiful Noise – The Neil Diamond Musical"
Copy










