Review: Beethoven’s Pastoral – ACO

Review: Beethoven’s Pastoral – ACO

By: NeesonPosted: November 19, 2026

Review: Beethoven’s Pastoral – ACO

By: NeesonNovember 19, 2026

Sunday 15 November 2026

Australian Chamber Orchestra

Sydney Opera House

Photos by Nic Walker

Review by Paul Neeson (Arts Wednesday)

Read more reviews from  Arts Wednesday here:

ACO Beethoven’s Pastoral

The Australian Chamber Orchestra celebrates two anniversaries in their current national tour – 20 years at the ACO for Principal Cellist, Timo-Veikko ‘Tipi’ Valve, and 250 years since the death of Beethoven. For this concert they have gone back to an age-old programming formula (“meat and two veg” according to Richard Tognetti) of Overture, Concerto and Symphony, and all music by the great German master. This is a formula that was the mainstay of symphony concerts for decades, but today a departure from the ACO’s usual programming of standard classical repertoire interspersed with very recent compositions. 

Also in a departure from the norm, the orchestra were using gut strings and bringing in period wind and brass instruments typical of the time of Beethoven. The modern piano, like the Steinway grand used in this concert, were only just being developed with the founding of the Pleyel Piano Factory in the year before the premiere of the Triple Concerto. 

ACO Beethoven’s Pastoral

First up in the program was Beethoven’s Coriolan Overture, a concert overture for a spoken tragic play titled Coriolan by Heinrich Joseph von Collin which premiered at a private concert in Vienna in 1807. The violence and the drama of the struggling Roman, Coriolanus is evident from the striking opening chords, executed with military precision by the ACO. The violas were the workhorses of this piece, carrying the rhythmic undercurrent through much of the eight minutes. Their flawless timing, along with the lower strings, allowed the conflict of the drama to unfold in time and space as the sfforzandi moved around the stage through the different sections of the orchestra.

The Concerto for Violin, Cello and Piano ‘Triple Concerto’ featured Artistic Director, Richard Tognetti, Tipi Valve and guest pianist Konstantin Shamray respectively as soloists. The work is essentially a concerto for String Trio and Orchestra, but in Beethoven’s hands it is a masterpiece of indelible beauty, melodic mastery and the epitome of classical form. The dialogue between the soloists was fluent and fluid, each having a fragment of the melodic line that melded seamlessly into a unified arc. It was hard to discern the transition point between violin and cello at times, their musicianship being so perfectly matched after 20 years of collaboration. The piano part was the glue that held it all together, with Shamray’s shimmering incandescent runs defining the tempo and the harmony perfectly.

ACO Beethoven’s Pastoral (Tipi Valve)

After the interval, the stage was reset complete with a large bouquet of flowers. A prop for the Pastoral Symphony perhaps? No it was an acknowledgement of Tipi’s service to the ACO. After a warm speech from Tognetti contrasting Tipi’s succinct use of words with his abundance of musical talent, his colleagues in the lower strings, Melissa Barnard and Julian Thompson on cello, and Maxime Bibeau on bass, joined him for an arrangement of a song from Schubert’s Winterreise that to me was one of the finest expressions of Romanticism I’ve ever heard. From the audience response, I think many in the crowd agreed with me.

And finally to Beethoven’s 6th Symphony ‘The Pastoral’. I think the master’s description of the 1st movement says it all – “Pleasant, cheerful feelings, that awaken within a person upon arrival in the countryside.” We were immediately transported to the German landscape, floating down a stream under the newly spring-leafed linden trees. The con sordino violins lulled us into a warm afternoon torpor. Never having heard this symphony with period instruments, I was amazed at the authenticity of the bird call imitations made more real than their contemporary counterparts. The flute (Melissa Farrow) was a nightingale, the oboe (Tatjana Zimre) a quail and the clarinet (Ernst Schlader) a cuckoo and as for the bassoon (Jane Gower) I was certain there was a duck in the hall.

ACO Beethoven’s Pastoral

The lively dances of the 3rd Movement began in middle Europe, but suddenly we were transported to a raucous B&S Ball in Brewarrina in outback NSW, with the cowboy boots raising the dust and black clouds brewing on the horizon. How did Tognetti do that? And of course the storm broke with tremulous cellos heralding the approaching thunder. The final movement, the Shepherd’s prayer after the storm, brought closure to the evening, and the capacity crowd at the Concert Hall burst into an eruption of appreciation, a fitting echo of the storm that had passed only two movements ago.

In this program we experienced violence and turmoil, mastery of form and orchestration, unforgettable melodic beauty and the tranquillity of the bucolic countryside – all the hallmarks of Beethoven’s genius. 

National tour runs until 25 November.

You can listen to a recent interview with Principal Cellist Tipi Valve below:

Share "Review: Beethoven’s Pastoral – ACO"

https://eastsidefm.org/review-beethovens-pastoral-aco/

Copy

Independent voices. Unexpected sounds.